Issue

Capistrano Beach Interim Armoring Permit

From ActCoastal

Month December
Year 2020
Summary On Wednesday, the Coastal Commission considered a two to five year permit request by Orange County Parks for the installation of new sandcube and riprap armoring to protect a parking lot and bike path at Capistrano Beach County Park in Dana Point. Included in the application was also after-the -fact authorization for removal work authorized under multiple emergency permits that were previously granted in response to damage caused by winter storms and high tide events at Capistrano Beach. Between 2004 and 2020, eight emergency permits were issued to OC Parks for work at this location, six of which were issued within the last five years. Coastal Commission staff recommended approval for two years with the condition that no new riprap armoring is allowed. The Surfrider Foundation raised concerns with approval of the permit stating the history of misuse of the emergency permit system and the need for a comprehensive retreat and living shoreline approach rather than perpetuating the unsafe conditions that continue to increase beach erosion. Commissioners approved the permit for a one year duration, with the possibility of extension for another one year based on OC Parks’ progress towards a long term shoreline management plan.
Outcome Red Dot.png
Outcome Description Commissioner Sara Aminzadeh raised safety concerns and pointed out the short sighted approach of utilizing emergency permits to manage the eroding beach. Commission Mike Wilson astutely pointed out that really a more comprehensive approach for managing the beach would be appropriate here by including the private Beach Road homeowners in a holistic solution. Commissioner Linda Escalante agreed with Commissioner Aminzadeh that the County’s approach has kicked the can down the road further and further is not appropriate. Commissioner Hart suggested shortening the permit duration to one year with a 6 month progress report on the long term plan development for the beach. This permit was approved 8-2 with Commissioners and Aminzadeh and Escalante in opposition.
Why You Should Care An additional two-to-five years delay will only cause further erosion and unsafe conditions at Capistrano Beach. OC Parks should be required to: 1.) submit their plan at this time for managed retreat and a living shoreline, and, 2.) remove the crumbling parking area and mitigate the loss of beach space once and for all. The Commission should have sent a clear message that emergency permits are not substitutes for long-term planning.
Image Save capo.jpg
Decision Type Coastal Development Permit
Staff Recommendation Approval with Conditions
Staff Report https://documents.coastal.ca.gov/reports/2020/12/SM-Th3/th3-12-2020-report.pdf
Lobbyist/Agent
Opposition to Project Surfrider Foundation
Coastal Act Policies Chapter 3

Voting Detail for Capistrano Beach Interim Armoring Permit


Individual vote detail for Issue: Capistrano Beach Interim Armoring Permit
CommissionerVote
Carole GroomBad Vote
Steve PadillaBad Vote
Donne BrownseyBad Vote
Dayna BochcoBad Vote
Katie RiceBad Vote
Linda EscalanteGood Vote
Mike WilsonBad Vote
Erik HowellAbsent for Vote
Roberto UrangaBad Vote
Effie Turnbull-SandersAbsent for Vote
Sara AminzadehGood Vote
Caryl HartBad Vote


Meeting Page

View Meeting Page for the meeting where this issue was discussed/voted on.