Issue

Solana Beach Sea Cave Fill-in

From ActCoastal

Month January
Year 2016
Summary This project would have involved maintaining and expanding the five existing sea cave infills with an additional 75-foot long notch in the coastal bluff. According to the applicant, the action was not currently critical to the structures on the coastal bluff, but was intended to protect beachgoers.

Commissioner Dayna Bochco asked the applicant to withdraw the application and resubmit a scaled-down test project version. Commissioner Greg Cox moved to approve the project and Commissioner Eric Howell seconded. Discussion continued with Commissioner Martha McClure strongly supporting Commissioner Bochco’s request. The applicant opted not to withdraw and thus the application was denied in a vote of 9:2.

Outcome Green Dot.png
Outcome Description Following discussion that circled from Commissioner Cox acknowledging that a “real time” test was needed to see how “erodible” the erodible concrete actually is and how it would affect the bluff to Commissioners Bochco and McClure agreeing there should be a test, but on a significantly smaller scale in order to minimize potential impacts, the CDP was denied in a 9:2 vote.
Why You Should Care Seacave infills can have negative effects on the surrounding bluffs that they become a part of, with bluffs continuing to erode around and behind the infill. The proposed infill material was “erodible” in theory, but no evidence supported that claim – and 75 feet of coastal bluff should not be used as a test subject. As climate change causes waves and weather to gain in intensity resulting in growing coastal impacts, hard-structures must not be our default response, but viewed with a critical eye.
Image Screen Shot 2016-02-24 at 9.49.36 AM.png
Decision Type Coastal Development Permit
Staff Recommendation Approval with Conditions
Staff Report http://documents.coastal.ca.gov/reports/2016/1/Th18a-1-2016.pdf
Lobbyist/Agent Walt Crampton
Opposition to Project San Diego County Chapter of the Surfrider Foundation
Coastal Act Policies Chapter 3 policies

Voting Detail for Solana Beach Sea Cave Fill-in


Individual vote detail for Issue: Solana Beach Sea Cave Fill-in
CommissionerVote
Wendy MitchellGood Vote
Martha McClureGood Vote
Mary LuevanoGood Vote
Effie Turnbull-SandersGood Vote
Greg CoxBad Vote
Carole GroomGood Vote
Roberto UrangaGood Vote
Steve KinseyGood Vote
Erik HowellBad Vote
Dayna BochcoGood Vote


Meeting Page

View Meeting Page for the meeting where this issue was discussed/voted on.