Browse wiki

Issue:O'Neal Solana Beach Seawall
DecisionType Coastal Development Permit Amendment  +
IssueImage Screen Shot 2017-02-22 at 12.08.46 PM.png  +
IssueMonth February  +
IssueOutcome Bad  +
IssueOutcomeDescription Commissioner Steve Kinsey moved to approve
Commissioner Steve Kinsey moved to approve staff’s recommendation to approve the amendment. He agreed that the 20-year permit reevaluation requirement is a significant burden for homeowners and subsequent homeowners, who may not even be aware of the requirement. Commissioners voted 7-1 to approve the amendment.
ioners voted 7-1 to approve the amendment.  +
IssueReason This is a troubling work around to seawall
This is a troubling work around to seawall permitting that could result in long term beach environment impacts. The incremental review of seawalls (as originally permitted) is viable and superior because it ensures the ability to review the seawall in light of changed circumstances over time. Linking seawalls to the life of a structure almost certainly ensures that homeowners will develop in a way that evades the definition of redevelopment and will prolong the life of the seawall, rather than redeveloping in a way that conforms with setback requirements that take sea level rise and climate change impacts into account and reduce the need for shoreline protection. In the end, the public and beaches lose. Coastal advocated have been fighting seawalls for over 40 years, when even then it was clear they created significant problems and don’t solve coastal erosion. Today, we are still fighting the same shortsighted planning decisions.
the same shortsighted planning decisions.  +
IssueSummary The proposed permit amendment seeks to rev
The proposed permit amendment seeks to revise the special conditions for a previously approved 256 ft. shoreline protection device in Solana Beach. The device was originally permitted in 2010 for 20 years to protect pre-Coastal Act development. The amendment would authorize the seawall and concrete backfill for the life of the bluff top structures. The seawall is located on a public bluff fronting five single-family residences. The existing seawall is currently authorized for a period of twenty years from the date of Commission approval of CDP #6-09-033 (October 14, 2010). This CDP amendment proposes to remove the twenty-year permit term, and instead tie the authorization of the seawall to the life of the existing threatened structures the armoring is required to protect. The applicant claims that this amendment will reduce the burden of the 20-year deed restriction for current homeowners without resulting in any additional coastal impacts. The Surfrider Foundation testified in opposition to the amendment, raising concern that without the 20 year permit trigger we may not have the opportunity to reevaluate this seawall, especially as circumstances change. Sea level rise and increased beach erosion are likely to increase over time, resulting in significant impacts to coastal access at locations fronting shoreline protection devices. In addition, one of the blufftop homes was recently permitted for redevelopment and has not yet begun construction – under the amendment this should trigger the requirement for reevaluation of the seawall. Despite these objections, Commissioners approved the amendment in a 7-1 vote.
ners approved the amendment in a 7-1 vote.  +
IssueYear 2,017  +
Lobbyist Jon Corn  +
Opposition Surfrider Foundation  +
Policies Chapter 3 Section 30235  +
StaffRecommendation Approval with Conditions  +
StaffReport https://documents.coastal.ca.gov/reports/2017/2/th18a-2-2017.pdf  +
Has query
This property is a special property in this wiki.
Issue:O'Neal Solana Beach Seawall + , Issue:O'Neal Solana Beach Seawall +
Categories Issues
Modification date
This property is a special property in this wiki.
22 February 2017 20:18:57  +
hide properties that link here 
Vote:Vote 02mr58ga0 + , Vote:Vote 0bfrys48e + , Vote:Vote 72mx87a2i + , Vote:Vote ekh6x63pm + , Vote:Vote iaoc13frp + , Vote:Vote il5lobk1q + , Vote:Vote in9i8b1ud + , Vote:Vote lrmbjyoh3 + , Vote:Vote o0fk9oxyj + , Vote:Vote z3q10gc7x + VoteIssue


Enter the name of the page to start browsing from.