+
Pro-Coast Outcome
-
Anti-Coast Outcome

All Issues

Niguel Shores Revetment in Dana Point
-
+

Meeting Date:

February 1, 2020

On Thursday, the Commission denied a proposed 1,250 ft. rock revetment at Strands Beach in Dana Point by Orange County Parks. The revetment would have protected private homes at the Niguel Shores Community Association at the expense of public beach space and mitigation funds from taxpayer dollars...

Shote Hotel ATF Permit
-
+

Meeting Date:

December 1, 2019

After settling an enforcement violation in May 2019 for operating out of conformance with the Coastal Act for nearly a decade, the Santa Monica-based Shore Hotel requested an after-the-fact approval permit for their continued operations...

Ocean View Plaza
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2019

Monterey developers requested a permit extension for a previously approved permit in 2008 for a major redevelopment of Cannery Row. The project would include retail, restaurant, condominiums, parking garages and more along both inland and seaward sides of Cannery Row...

Pacific Grove LCP Update
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2019

The City of Pacific Grove proposed to update its local coastal program, originally certified in 1989. Notably, updates include new sections related to sea level rise, flood and hazard abatement, environmentally sensitive habitat areas (ESHA), wetland protection, water quality enhancement, and tribal/archaeological protections...

Cayucos Sanitary District Chevron Outfall Repurposing
-
+

Meeting Date:

September 1, 2019

The Cayucos Sanitary District (CSD) proposed to repurpose an existing Chevron Estero Marine Terminal offshore pipeline for use as a treated wastewater effluent outfall with discharge from a new tertiary Water Resource Recovery Facility that the CSD is constructing further inland...

Gaviota State Beach Pier Repair
-
+

Meeting Date:

September 1, 2019

The California Department of Parks and Recreation (State Parks) submitted a coastal development permit for the repair and reconstruction of the pier at Gaviota State Park as well as the installation of a rip-rap seawall...

2 Mirada Half Moon Bay
-
+

Meeting Date:

July 1, 2019

The Coastal Commission reviewed an application by 2 Mirada Ownership Group and Casa Mira Homeowner’s Association to construct an approximately 250-ft. long tied-back concrete seawall, fronting both residential development and a portion of the California Coastal Trail in Half Moon Bay...

Newport Beach Encroachments
-
+

Meeting Date:

July 1, 2019

The Commission acted on the City of Newport Beach’s request to amend both the Land Use Plan and Local Implementation Plan portion of the certified LCP to expand the allowable residential beach encroachments zone on the Balboa Peninsula from 1400 E...

Ritz-Carlton Half Moon Bay Public Access Violation
-
+

Meeting Date:

June 1, 2019

The Ritz-Carlton Hotel in Half Moon Bay opened in 2001 in a location that was historically used for public access to the coast. As a condition of the coastal development permit, the hotel was required to maintain public use and coastal access. Unfortunately, that condition was never met and public access was not provided for nearly two decades...

San Onofre State Beach Seawall
-
+

Meeting Date:

June 1, 2019

California State Parks proposed to retain an 800-foot long riprap revetment along Surf Beach at San Onofre State Beach. The seawall was originally constructed pursuant to an emergency permit issued in February 2017. The emergency revetment was installed as a temporary measure to protect the beachfront road...

Trafalgar Canyon San Clemente
-
+

Meeting Date:

June 1, 2019

Applicants of this coastal development permit proposed an 8,000 Sq. Ft. residential development that would be located in a protected coastal canyon. The lot contains environmentally sensitive habitat that would be damaged, which is not allowed under the Coastal Act and is therefore illegal, and the grading required would create an unstable bluff and thus be unsafe...

Hollister Ranch Parcel 36 Appeal
-
+

Meeting Date:

May 1, 2019

Commissioners Carole Groom and Steve Padilla appealed a Santa Barbara County approved coastal development permit for the construction of a swimming pool and in-ground spa on Parcel No. 36 on Hollister Ranch. The parcel contains an existing home, guest house and barn...

Shore Hotel Coastal Development Permit
-
+

Meeting Date:

May 1, 2019

As a separate matter, the Commission heard an after-the-fact coastal development permit (CDP) for the Shore Hotel. In 2009, Sunshine Enterprises obtained Commission approval to replace two lower-cost motels with a lower-to-moderately priced hotel...

Shore Hotel Enforcement Action
-
+

Meeting Date:

May 1, 2019

In 2009, Sunshine Enterprises obtained Commission approval to replace two lower-cost motels with a lower-to-moderately priced hotel. However, that permit expired before the developer began construction making the subsequent construction was unpermitted...

Encinitas New Blufftop Home (Hurst)
-
+

Meeting Date:

March 1, 2019

Coastal Commission staff recommended denial of a coastal development permit application to construct a new home in Encinitas. The application consisted of demolition of an existing home and construction of a significantly larger home including a basement on a blufftop lot...

Enforcement - Marin Wetlands Fill
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2019

This enforcement item addresses unpermitted grading and fill of over 13 acres of wetlands in Marin County. The wetlands impacted are part of the Estero de San Antonio which empties into Bodega Bay...

Laguna Beach Setbacks Appeal
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2019

The City of Laguna Beach had approved a permit for a 1600 square-foot addition and remodel of a blufftop home with additional structures, grading and landscaping; the proposed renovations would have expanded the floor area beyond an additional 50-percent, making it a major remodel...

Solana Beach Joint Seawalls (Pacific Ave)
-
+

Meeting Date:

March 1, 2019

Coastal Commission staff recommended approval of shoreline armoring in a joint application for three homes in Solana Beach. The homes at 235 and 241 Pacific Avenue were constructed prior to enactment of the Coastal Act...

Moss Landing Harbor Dredging Authorization
-
+

Meeting Date:

February 1, 2019

The Moss Landing Harbor District requested approval of a 10-year CDP to dredge and dispose of sediments to restore navigable depths in berths in the Moss Landing Harbor. The permit would authorize dredging and disposal of up to 550,000 cubic yards of material over the 10-year life of the permit, with no more than 80,000 cubic yards in any given year...

Moss Landing Harbor 10-Year Dredging Operations
-
+

Meeting Date:

December 1, 2018

The Moss Landing Harbor District requested a coastal development permit for approval of a 10-year dredge project and to dispose of sediments to restore navigable depths in berths in the Moss Landing Harbor and the North Harbor channel...

2018 Sea Level Rise Science Update
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2018

Batiquitos Lagoon Public Access Trail
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2018

The Commission heard an enforcement action to resolve long-standing violations of more than 30 years related to the failure to construct a public access trail at a residential community in Carlsbad known as the Rosalena community....

La Jolla Public Access - Kretowicz
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2018

The Coastal Commission reviewed a permit amendment to replace decorative paving currently within the City of La Jolla’s Princess Street public right-of-way with new granite porcelain tiles and signage identifying public access to the pocket beach...

Long Beach LCP Amendment - Demolish and Rebuild
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2018

The City of Long Beach’s proposed LCP Amendment is a triennial general update. One of the primary proposed changes is the revision of the definitions of “demolish” and “rebuild.” These definitions provide a threshold...

Mavericks Challenge - Surf Contest
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2018

The Coastal Commission reviewed a permit application by the World Surf League to authorize a special event permit for a one-day “Mavericks Challenge” surf competition near Pillar Point Harbor in a window of time between October 1, 2018 and March 31, 2018...

Rancho Cuarta - Hollister Ranch Appeal
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2018

Commissioners Aaron Peskin and Carole Groom appealed two Santa Barbara County combined permits for development in Hollister Ranch. The permits include construction of a single-family home with a guesthouse, ancillary structures and replacement of a bridge...

Setbacks in Solana Beach - Harris
-
+

Meeting Date:

October 1, 2018

The Coastal Commission reviewed a permit application for a remodel of an existing blufftop home in Solana Beach. Coastal Commission staff recommended denial of the application since the majority of the development would be located in a non-conforming, hazardous location...

Santa Monica Mountains - Cease and Desist Orders
-
+

Meeting Date:

September 1, 2018

In 2004, the Coastal Commission staff discovered unpermitted development in the Santa Monica Mountains which was the subject of the consent cease and desist and restoration orders. The property where this occurred is part of a unique ecosystem..

Encinitas Blufftop Setback
-
+

Meeting Date:

August 1, 2018

Two vacant unarmored blufftop lots in Encinitas were proposed for consolidation and construction of a new two-story, 3,000-plus square foot home and basement with a 40-foot setback from the bluff edge...

Gaviota Coast Plan
-
+

Meeting Date:

August 1, 2018

The proposed Gaviota Coast Plan will function as a new stand-alone area plan in the County’s LCP. The plan covers several important topics including environmentally sensitive habitat areas (ESHA), agriculture, principle permitted uses and public access and recreation...

Illegal Seawall Laguna Beach
-
+

Meeting Date:

August 1, 2018

Cease and Desist Order CCC-18-CD-02 and Administrative Penalty CCC-18-AP-02 As documented in the staff report, the property owners have engaged in extensive unpermitted rebuilding of their private residence...

Resolution on Sea Level Rise and Shoreline Preservation
-
+

Meeting Date:

August 1, 2018

Governor Brown is the co-chair of the 2018 Climate Action Summit. The purpose of the summit is to underscore the urgent need for action on climate change to avoid most devastating impacts and to call on governments to do more. The goal is to spur action in key areas and call on participants to make new commitments to increase climate resilience...

Wave Resort Dana Point
-
+

Meeting Date:

August 1, 2018

In October 2017, the Surfrider Foundation South Orange County Chapter appealed a luxury hotel development approved by the City of Dana Point through Local Coastal Development Permit CDP17-0008...

Navy 5-Year Training and Testing
-
+

Meeting Date:

June 1, 2018

The U.S. Department of the Navy submitted a consistency determination for their 5-Year Military Readiness Training and Testing Program Activities in Southern California. The training elements involve extensive use of active sonar and explosives...

Hueneme Beach Sediment Deposition
-
+

Meeting Date:

May 1, 2018

The Oxnard Harbor District, as part of the Port of Hueneme Deepening Project, proposed to place 30,000 cubic yards of sediment dredged from the Port of Hueneme at two sites that have been identified to receive the dredged material...

San Francisco Western Shoreline Area Plan LCP Amendment
-
+

Meeting Date:

May 1, 2018

The City and County of San Francisco proposed to amend their Land Use Plan (LUP), also referred to as the Western Shoreline Area Plan, by adding new policies related to coastal hazards. The proposed amendment primarily addresses erosion, flooding, and sea level rise...

Santa Barbara County short-term rentals
-
+

Meeting Date:

May 1, 2018

Santa Barbara County requested an amendment to its Local Coastal Program (LCP) to add new regulations to address short-term rentals and homestays. As proposed, the amendment excludes short-term rentals from residential zoning districts, except within a proposed Short-term Rentals Coastal Historic Overlay in the residentially zoned neighborhood of Miramar Beach...

Cease and Desist Order OceanAire Apartments Pacifica
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2018

On Thursday, the Commission heard a cease and desist order involving the collapse and closure, since December 2016, of a public access stairway and trail system that provides public access down a steep coastal bluff in Pacifica...

Solana Beach Defacto Seawall Reconsideration
-
+

Meeting Date:

April 1, 2018

In December 2017, the Commission denied an application to install a 90-foot long, preemptive “erodible” concrete seawall. The applicant then filed for reconsideration, the subject of this item.

Opal Cliffs Private Access Substantial Issue
-
+

Meeting Date:

March 1, 2018

The County-approved project that is the subject of this appeal is the result of a long and protracted case first initiated by Commission enforcement staff in 2006. While the permitting history between the Coastal Commission and the Opal Cliffs Recreation District...

Reconsideration of Monroe/Sloan Erodible Concrete Seawall
-
+

Meeting Date:

March 1, 2018

In December, 2017, the Commission denied a permit application to install a 90-foot long preemptive “erodible” concrete seawall. The applicant claims this decision merits reconsideration on the basis that the Commission committed three errors of law...

San Francisco PUC Redundancy Infrastructure
-
+

Meeting Date:

March 1, 2018

The City and County of San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) is proposing to construct new above-ground and subsurface redundancy wastewater infrastructure within a sea level rise and coastal hazard flood zone on the corner of the Great Highway and Sloat Boulevard fronting south Ocean Beach in San Francisco...

Cayucos Del Mar Hotel
-
+

Meeting Date:

February 1, 2018

The Cayucos Del Mar Hotel applicant, Frank DeCicco, proposed to subdivide 18 legal lots of record into three lots (two residential lots and one commercial lot) and to construct a 19-room, moderate cost, hotel (the “Cayucos Del Mar Hotel”) with associated underground hotel parking and landscaping...

Offshore Oil and Gas Opposition Letter
-
+

Meeting Date:

February 1, 2018

The Commission voted on a draft letter to the federal Bureau of Ocean and Energy management expressing the concern and strong opposition to the proposed federal 2019-2024 Draft Proposed National Oil and Gas Leasing Program...

San Clemente LUP Update
-
+

Meeting Date:

February 1, 2018

The LCP amendment consists of a comprehensive update to the certified City of San Clemente Land Use Plan (LUP), including the alignment of the California Coastal Trail, alternative parking strategies, limitations on preferential parking, protection of existing and provision of affordable overnight accommodations and more...

Malibu Parking Restriction
-
+

Meeting Date:

December 1, 2017

This item is an appeal of Local Coastal Development Permit to implement a 30-minute parking restriction between the hours of 2 a.m. and 4 a.m. daily, and posting of parking restriction signs issued by the City of Malibu...

Solana Beach Erodible Concrete Seawall
-
+

Meeting Date:

December 1, 2017

The proposed project is for a CDP that would fill an existing notch in a coastal bluff with an erodible concrete mixture colored and sculpted to resemble the natural bluff. The notch is located on a city-owned beach fronting two existing single family residences in the City of Solana Beach...

Wave Resort Substantial Issue
-
+

Meeting Date:

December 1, 2017

This item is an appeal by the Surfrider Foundation of City of Dana Point Local Coastal Development Permit No. 17-0008 approved with conditions for the construction of a two-story, 35,000 square foot commercial development that consists of a 57-room hotel...

Cojo Jalama Ranch
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2017

This enforcement action addresses unpermitted development activities that were conducted across a large coastal property, known as the Cojo and Jalama Ranches in Santa Barbara County, which occupies an 11-mile swath of coastline on either side of Point Conception...

Sharp Park Coastal Armoring
-
+

Meeting Date:

November 1, 2017

San Francisco Recreation and Parks Department (SFRPD) sought an after-the-fact authorization of a previously constructed shoreline armoring structure that is located seaward of the Sharp Park Golf Course in Pacifica, consisting of an earthen berm approximately 3,200 feet in total length...